Launchpad S2 sets multiple Port 1 interrupt flags

Hello, I am trying to have an MSP430G2203 in a launchpad perform 2 different operations. S2 should pulse led 2 when pressed. (this part works) The mode of the pulse is supposed to be determined by a switch on P1.4.

However when I press S1 P1IFG is being set on bits 3,4,5 and in ISR runs through both if statements. This changes the "Mode" every time S2 is pressed.

Here is my Code:

/*
 * main.c
 */

#include  "msp430g2203.h"


#define Trigger     BIT3             // will change to P2.3 in final code
#define ModeSwitch     BIT4            // will change to P1.0 in final code
#define Solenoid     BIT6
#define LED1        BIT0


unsigned int Dwell=100000;
unsigned int RateOfFire=100000;
unsigned int Mode=0;

void SetIO(void);
void ConfigClocks(void);
void FaultRoutine(void);

void ModeSelect(void);
void FullAuto(void);
void SemiAuto(void);
void ThreeBallBurst(void);
void SixBallBurst(void);

void main(void) {
    
      WDTCTL = WDTPW + WDTHOLD;            // Stop watchdog timer

      ConfigClocks();
      SetIO();

      while(1){
          _BIS_SR(LPM3_bits + GIE); // Enter LPM3 w/interrupt
          }

}

void SetIO(void){

    P1DIR = Solenoid;                      // P1.6 output (solenoid fire)
    P1REN = 0;                            // Enable pull-up resistor
    P1OUT = 0;                          // outputs off

    //Set Input Interrupts
    P1IE |= (Trigger | ModeSwitch);     // P1.3 interrupt enabled
    P1IES |= (Trigger | ModeSwitch);     // P1.3 Hi/lo edge
    P1IFG &=~(Trigger | ModeSwitch);     // P1.3 IFG cleared

    P2DIR = 0X02;                        // set eyes output
    P2OUT = 0;                            // Turn off eyes
}

void ConfigClocks(void){

     if (CALBC1_1MHZ ==0xFF || CALDCO_1MHZ == 0xFF)
         FaultRoutine();                          // If calibration data is erased
                                                             // run FaultRoutine()
           BCSCTL3 |= LFXT1S_0;                     // LFXT1 = Normal Operation
           IFG1 &= ~OFIFG;                          // Clear OSCFault flag
           BCSCTL2 |= SELM_3 + DIVM_0;               // MCLK = LXFT1/1

}

void FaultRoutine(void)
 {
   P1OUT = BIT0;                            // P1.0 on (red LED)
   while(1);                                 // TRAP
 }

// Port 1 interrupt service routine
#pragma vector=PORT1_VECTOR
__interrupt void Port_1(void)
{

    if(P1IFG&Trigger){

        switch(Mode){
        case 0: SemiAuto();break;
        case 1: FullAuto();break;
        case 2: ThreeBallBurst();break;
        case 3: SixBallBurst();break;
        }

        //SixBallBurst();

    }
    if(P1IFG&ModeSwitch){
        ModeSelect();
    }
    P1IFG &= ~(Trigger | ModeSwitch);     // P1.3 and P1.4 IFG cleared
}

void ModeSelect(void){

        Mode +=1;

    if(Mode>3){
        Mode=0;
    }


}

void SemiAuto(void){

      P1OUT = Solenoid;                 // Turn On Solenoid
      //_delay_cycles(100000);            // SET THE "ON" TIME FOR SOLENOID

      P1OUT = 0X00;                     // Turn off Solenoid

}

void FullAuto(void){

    while ((P1IN & Trigger) == 0x00){
          P1OUT = Solenoid;                 // Turn On Solenoid
          _delay_cycles(100000);            // SET THE "ON" TIME FOR SOLENOID


          P1OUT = 0X00;                     // Turn off Solenoid
          _delay_cycles(100000);

    }

}

void ThreeBallBurst(void){

        int burst = 3;
        int count = 0;
        for (count=0;count <burst;count++){
              P1OUT = Solenoid;                 // green LED on
              _delay_cycles(100000);        // SET THE "ON" TIME FOR SOLENOID

              P1OUT = 0X00;                      // green LED off
              _delay_cycles(100000);

        }

}

void SixBallBurst(void){

        int burst = 6;
        int count = 0;
        for (count=0;count <burst;count++){
              P1OUT = Solenoid;                 // green LED on
              _delay_cycles(100000);        // SET THE "ON" TIME FOR SOLENOID

              P1OUT = 0X00;                      // green LED off
              _delay_cycles(100000);

        }

}