As one of the most critical design parameters, the choice of loop bandwidth involves trade-offs between jitter, phase noise, lock time and spurs. The loop bandwidth that is optimal for jitter, BWJIT, can often be the best choice for many clocking applications, such as data converter clocking. In cases where BWJIT is not the best choice, starting there is still the first step to finding the optimal loop bandwidth.
In Figure 1, the offset where the phase-locked loop (PLL) and voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) noise cross, BWJIT (about 140kHz) optimizes jitter by minimizing the area under the curve.
Figure 1: Optimal jitter bandwidth
Although this bandwidth, BWJIT, is optimal for jitter, it is not for phase noise, lock time and spurs. Table 1 gives a relative idea of the impact of loop bandwidth on these performance metrics.
Table 1: Impact of loop bandwidth on critical parameters
To illustrate Table 1, consider the simulation in Figure 2, which shows the effect of varying the loop bandwidth. The lock time and jitter-normalized metrics are the percentage increase from the lowest value shown in Figure 2. The spur and phase-noise metrics are the decibel increase from the lowest value shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Impact of loop bandwidth on normalized performance
As Figure 1 predicted, the optimal jitter is indeed best for a loop bandwidth around 140kHz. Increasing the loop bandwidth beyond this benefits lock time and 10kHz phase noise, but degrades the spur and phase noise at 1MHz offset.
Thus, a good approach to choosing loop bandwidth might be to choose the optimal jitter bandwidth (BWJIT) as a starting point, then increase to improve lock time or close in phase noise, or decrease to improve far-out phase noise or spurs.
Have questions about choosing the correct loop bandwidth? Sign in and leave a comment below.