The value of a charger IC over a discrete solution for vacuum robots


As technology continues to boom, interconnectivity between devices enables the rapid growth of automated homes. The development of the vacuum robot came about as a result of the convenience of manipulating home equipment through wireless connectivity and remote accessibility.

A vacuum robot eliminates the need for manual floor cleaning by setting schedules to ensure a consistently clean home. In addition to convenience and time savings, these compact vacuum robots – unlike traditional, hefty vacuums – relieve the strain of running a vacuum by easily reaching tough nooks and crannies associated with furniture, walls and corners.

To maximize the floor space cleaned, a vacuum robot must optimize its running time. Thus, a battery-charging solution requires astute consideration in vacuum robot design. Taking an input voltage of approximately 19-20V from a charging dock, most vacuum robots on the market employ rechargeable four-cell lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries to power their systems. Extending the run time of these batteries and cutting battery costs requires efficient utilization of the battery pack to its fullest capacity. Figure 2 illustrates the vacuum robot system and highlights its battery-management solutions.

Figure 1: Vacuum robot system power diagrams

You can implement the charging circuit in several ways. The discrete solution uses a simple DC/DC converter to charge the battery. The system’s microcontroller (MCU) mimics a CC-CV charging curve by controlling the on/off switching of the MOSFETs. While the discrete solution may be inexpensive, its inaccurate charge voltage, low switching frequency and lack of built-in battery protections contribute to additional costs and poorer performance than a charger integrated circuit (IC).

Alternatively, charger IC solutions offer high charge voltage accuracies, high switching frequencies and enhanced battery protections. While some designers may choose a discrete solution with a lower cost than the charger IC solution, the benefits of a charger IC impressively outweigh the price difference.

Vacuum robots on the market vary in run time, ranging from about 60 to 150 minutes. Maximizing the amount of cleaned surface area relies on the robot’s operational period, making optimal run time a key selling point for consumers; just several extra minutes could make the difference between an entirely clean and partially dirty home.

TI’s charger IC such as the bq24725A or bq24610 offers a high-accuracy charge voltage of ±0.5% compared to a low-cost DC/DC converter charge voltage accuracy of ±5%. Due to the small ±0.5% charge voltage accuracy, this charger IC maximizes battery capacity, which ultimately extends the robot’s run time.

Figure 3 describes the battery voltage versus the depth of discharge (DOD) of a 4.2 Li-ion battery at room temperature. Based on the charge voltage accuracies of the charger IC and several discrete solutions, the data maps several DOD points to battery voltages, which translate to run time. As shown in Figure 3 and its associated data in Table 1, the TI charger IC solution significantly maximizes capacity over discrete charging solutions.

Figure 2: Li-ion DOD versus battery voltage


Table 1: Charge voltage accuracy mapped to battery capacity

 Battery capacity ultimately translates to device run time and the cost difference of batteries with a certain run-time goal. For example, take a vacuum robot that uses a TI charger IC solution with ±0.5% charge voltage accuracy that runs for 120 minutes. The same vacuum robot using a DC/DC converter as a discrete solution with a charge voltage accuracy of ±5% would only run for 55 minutes. Therefore, the loss in capacity due to a less accurate charge voltage, as shown in Table 1, significantly diminishes the run time of the robot.

From a monetary standpoint, a battery pack for this application costs about $20. The 56% capacity lost in this example requires you to purchase $11 more in capacity. This extra 65 minutes of run time would allow the robot to clean several additional rooms, and the cost savings due to maximized capacity quantifies the value of using a charger IC solution.

Charger IC solutions yield high switching frequencies and in turn require small, low-cost inductors. For example, TI’s bq24725A, with a switching frequency of 750kHz, typically uses a 4.7µH inductor sized at 28mm2. Alternatively, a discrete solution with a switching frequency of only 50kHz requires a larger, 75µH or greater inductor covering about 113mm2 of board space. Along with saving solution size, the charger IC’s inductor is roughly two times less expensive than the discrete solution’s inductor, depending on inductor choice.

From a design perspective, a charger IC advantageously offers a complete, sophisticated suite of battery safety features, including input overcurrent, charge overcurrent, battery overvoltage, thermal shutdown, battery shorted to ground, inductor short and field-effect transistor (FET) short protections. On the other hand, a discrete solution would have to use its MCU to implement battery protections, and damage could occur to the battery by the time the MCU detects faults due to its slow response times. Therefore, a charger IC protects the battery in any worst-case scenarios while eliminating the need for you to create your own battery protections.

For additional design flexibility, the TI multicell switching charger portfolio provides options for stand-alone and host-controlled topologies. A stand-alone charger such as the bq24610 controls voltage and current limits with external circuitry elements, facilitating simple implementation. A host-controlled charger such as the bq24725A or bq24773 uses I2C or SMBus to program the limits, saving bill-of-materials cost by employing the calculating power of the system’s already-existing MCU.

A charger IC offers a myriad of advantages over common discrete charging solutions for vacuum robots. Although a discrete solution may be more economical initially, a charger IC solution provides a significantly longer run time, system cost savings and a simpler design implementation than the discrete alternative. Ultimately, the benefits of the complete charger IC solution outweigh the initial cost savings of the discrete charging solution.

Additional resources:

  • Very good blog to understand TI Charger advantages in Vacuum Robot. Besides the advantages of extending battery capacity (achieved by higher charging voltage accuracy) and small solution size (achieved by increasing switching frequency and shrinking inductor size), there are some other very good features that can bring more advantages, higher charging current accuracy is a very important one. BQ24773 can reach +/-3% charging current accuracy, when compared with discrete solution (which is about +/-50%) . Since for Li-Ion battery, the charging process will go through states such as pre-charge state, Constant Current Fast Charge state and Constant Voltage Charge state. The pre-charge state will charge the battery with a small constant current to reach Vcc(may be 2.8V to 3V), then Fast constant current charging (about 1C or higher charge current) will be forced into battery until the battery voltage reach Vcv(may be 4.2V). The Constant voltage charge will be started until the charging current reach 10% of the fast constant charging current. Since most of the charging time is wasted on the constant voltage state, so a higher charging current detection accuracy will make the charging process stay longer in high current state and reduce the charging time. Besides, higher voltage accuracy will also reduce the charging time because the battery can stay longer in the fast constant current charging state and most of the energy is transferred in this fast charging state. In a word, TI charger solution can achieve capacity extension, smaller solution size, shorter charging time as well as better battery protection. Actually, customer can get all these good features without paying more. This can be achieved in 2 aspect, 1), since TI charger solution can drain the most of battery capacity, which in turn, if the customer want, they can use smaller capacity battery and save cost. 2), high switching frequency will let the customer use smaller inductor, also save system cost.