This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

SN65220: transient suppressor failed in field in a way that I have been unable to replicate.

Part Number: SN65220

My design uses SN65220DBV for ESD protection on a input bus that is meant to carry 3.3V logic signals.  SN65220 device GND pins (2 and 5) are connected to product chassis GND and device A and B pins (6 and 4) are each connected to a signal. The intent is that each signal will be independently clipped between 0V and 3-5V. On a unit which was returned from the field I found that the pin4-to-GND path on one device had failed short and always had a resistance of approx. 15 ohms. The fault seems to be bipolar, by which I mean I measured the same small resistance which way I attached the leads of a DMM in resistance mode and the same small Vf  no matter which way I attached the leads of a DMM in diode mode.  

The faulted SN65220 was shorting out an input channel that had passed test before shipping the unit, so the damage must have occurred in the field. I am trying to determine what sort of event may have damaged it.  As a transient supression device, it seems unlikely that is was itself damaged by an ESD event.  Many transient devices can fail if DC voltage is applied to them which is beyond their clipping voltages, so I tried emulating this.  On the surviving channel of the part (pin6-to-GND) I intentionally applied DC voltages below GND and above 6V.  As expected this caused damage to the part. However, the negative DC voltage seemed to create a fault that was unidirectional, and the positive overvoltage seems to have blown the channel completely open. Neither conditions really replicated the bidirectional 15ohm short seen on the channel that was damaged in the field. Do you have any ideas on possible root causes of a persistent, bidirectional short?

  • Hi Samuel,

    Let me check in to this for you to see if we have ever come across this issue before. Thank you for your patience.!

    Very Respectfully,
    Brian Dempsey
  • Hi Samuel,

    To answer your question, the bi-directional short typically is the intended fail mode of the Zener diode internal to the device. For the resistance you are seeing, if the Zener is indeed fusing short, this will cause any voltage to reach the internal transistor Q1, allowing conduction to GND. Regarding the resistance you are seeing, it looks like this may be due to the internal resistor R1 shown below in conjunction with the fused short Zener.

    As far as the cause, there is no way to be sure. If your testing produced different results than that seen on the damaged component, there could be a multitude of reasons for the difference. I hope this helps!

    Very Respectfully,

    Brian Dempsey