This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

LAUNCHXL-CC1310: TIDA-010050 water meter design

Part Number: LAUNCHXL-CC1310
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: CC1310, TIDA-01228, CSD23285F5, TIDA-010050, CC1312R, CSD23280F3

HI,

i saw ti have new water meter design , on 

the design was base on CC1312R2,  may i ask can i use CC1310 to implement this?

Furthermore,

i find this one is using the DAC  comparator while the one of TIDA -01228

is using the TDC .

1)Any benefit of using the DAC instead of the TDC?

2) according to tida 01005

"The LC excitationpulseis generatedfromthe NANDgate,triggeredby the digitalIO pin of theCC1312Rdeviceand RC circuit.In the Low-powerwaterflow measurementwith inductivesensingreferencedesign, the triggersignalwas directlyprovidedfromthe IO pin of the CC1310,and the triggertime of 250 ns was used.For one triggerevent,the triggerpin shouldbe drivenHIGHfor a singleprocessingunit and thenreleased.Becausethe sensorcontrollerin the CC1312Rdeviceusesa 2-MHzclockfor low powermode,the durationfor the HIGHstateis 1 μs (eachCPUinstructiontakes2 clockcycles).Therefore,the RC circuithereis usedto providea shortertriggertime.DifferentRC parameterscan be implementedfor differenttriggertime requirements."

so what is the point of using NAND gate to trigger instead of directly from IO?

3) In the reference design, the use of MOSFET was csd23285f5, this component is not easy for us to make prototype,

any other alternative you can suggest?

when considering other alternative, which factor we should focus ?

thanks

Jeff

  • Hi Jeff,

    Let me followup with the designer of this board and get back to you in couple of days.

    With Regards,

  • Hi Jeff,

    the TIDA-010050 is the adaptation and optimization of TIDA-01228 for the CC13x2/26x2 family of devices.

    The Sensor Controller Engine (SCE) in CC1312R has been improved for lower power over the SCE in CC13x0 (previous TI Wireless MCU generation).

    See answers below:

    1. DAC together with 2MHz mode achieves much lower power than using TDC with 24 MHz mode (see TIDA-010050 results compared to TIDA-01228)
    2. NAND with its RC-network enables shorter trigger pulse than 1 us
    3. This device got selected due to low-cost and 0.5mm pitch (CSD23280F3 for example has even smaller pitch). We do not have an alternative FET recommendation. 

    In summary, it is not possible to use the solution from TIDA-010050 on CC1310.

    But you could consider upgrading the CC1310 to CC1312R (you need also a faster Oscillator with 48 MHz) if you reelly need the lower power performance, see AppNote https://www.ti.com/lit/an/swra640c/swra640c.pdf

    Regards,

    Milen