On/Off report attributes strange behaviors

Two ZCL Payloads are the same. Is it possible an issue on sniffer sw?

I use CC2351 USB dongle as the sniffer, how to check if it is the latest firmware and where to get it if i run an old version?

I try to flash firmware from C:\Program Files (x86)\Texas Instruments\SmartRF Tools\Packet Sniffer\bin\general\firmware\sniffer_fw_cc2531.hex this is the latest firmware? And it is show the same in Ubiqua 2.2

I mean it might be the issue from Ubiqua 2.2 not CC2531 sniffer FW itself.

I think it is not likely to occur, that why i ask this is: my hub (main with cc2531) not recognize on/off state from SampleLight but the reference device do. I can control SampleLight on/off, but when i use the button on the board, it not send back to ZC accurately, the packet are so difference, with SampleLight it is still 0x0000 but it show Reserved but from the right it show: [On,Off]

Can you attach your sniffer log and specify the ON/OFF status reports which are from SampleLight and reference device?

This is the Ubiqua log, SampleLight is: 0x46A4, reference device is: 0x50AB

on_off_logs.zip

Try to use correct seqNum in last parameter of your zcl_SendReportCmd.

Yes, but how i get accurate value? I see reference device seqNum (Transaction Sequence Number) change overtime, like +1 las seqnum. But where is secNum store after each command or how to generate it?

Update: I am not use easy mode

Just use a variable start with 1 and increase it every time you send toggle command.

I add seqnum like you said, but package is still the same, the ZC could not process the on/off attributes update

Try to use ZCL_FRAME_CLIENT_SERVER_DIR in your zcl_sendReport.

I have already use it from the start:

  //report state
  zclSampleLightSeqNumState++;
  zclReportCmd_t rptcmd;
  rptcmd.numAttr = 1;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrID = ATTRID_ON_OFF;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].dataType = ZCL_DATATYPE_BOOLEAN;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrData = (void *)(&zclSampleLight_OnOff);

  // Set destination address to indirect
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addrMode = (afAddrMode_t)Addr16Bit;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addr.shortAddr = 0;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.endPoint=1;
  zcl_SendReportCmd(SAMPLELIGHT_ENDPOINT,&zclSampleLight_DstAddr, ZCL_CLUSTER_ID_GEN_ON_OFF, &rptcmd, ZCL_FRAME_CLIENT_SERVER_DIR, false, zclSampleLightSeqNumState )

Also use true instead of false in zcl_sendReport.

Yes, but the on/off attributes like i first post. Here the logs. I don't know why it is too complicate. The reference device still work fine.

on_off_logs_2.zip

Yes, now it show correct value in the Ubiqua frame, like my reference device. But i still face problem. The ZC (c2531) could not update it SampleLight (as Router) state with the on/off Report Attributes, the reference device can work with same packet structure.

Can you attach your latest sniffer log?

Yes, please check the logs. I remove all the device, only left SampleLight. First two command on/off send from ZC and next i press onboard button to turn it on/off. The behavior i want is the ZC can update the SampleLight on/off state when i press onboard button.

on_off_logs_3.zip

The sniffer log looks good. Does your ZC use 1 as endpoint and is ZC based on Z-Stack?

Yes, it use 1 as endpoint and destpoint, i replace 8 by 1 in the samplelight. You can see in the first log, the reference device use the same info and it work, i dont't know why, i just change build symbol by: xHOLD_AUTO_START and xZCL_EZMODE, add code for report on/off state, nothing more

How do you judge you don’t receive it?

on_off_logs_4.zip

I am not sure, i am a newbie. But i try to change SampleLight to End device,  i see some endless Data request package.

You can check the log from 0xCC48. But i can control it from ZC with on/off, but not update back like when i start thread.

End device would do data requests every second by default in Z-Stack. I see you send on/off status report to coordinator so how do you check if Coordinator receives on/off status.

Thank you. It is OK now