Because of the Thanksgiving holiday in the U.S., TI E2E™ design support forum responses may be delayed from November 25 through December 2. Thank you for your patience.

  • State Resolved
  • Locked Locked
  • Replies 6 replies
  • Answers 1 answer
  • Subscribers 32 subscribers
  • Views 276 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Support feedback
Options
Options
Similar topics

This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

ESD2CAN24-Q1: Alternative recommendation

Antoine Chapuis1
Expert 4505 points
Part Number: ESD2CAN24-Q1

Hi team,

Can you please share your alternatives for the parts below? bomcross tool is not giving exact PNs but I see we should have ESD for LIN and CAN here.

SMA6T18AY

SM6T36CAY

ESDLIN1524BJ

ESDCAN03-2BWY

SM15T68CAY

ESDCAN02-2BWY 

Best regards, Antoine

  • 0
    TI__Expert 4400 points

    Hi Antoine, 

    Please see the table for our best recommendations:

    Competitor TI P2P Notes
    SMA6T18AY TVS1400DRVR Best recommendation we have
    SM6T36CAY TVS3301DRBR Best recommendation we have
    ESDLIN1524BJ ESD1LIN24DYFRQ1 yes

    ESDCAN03-2BWY

    ESD2CANFD24DBZRQ1,

    ESD2CANXL24DBZRQ1

    CAN FD <= 5 Mbps

    CAN XL <= 20 Mbps
    SM15T68CAY no TI device Unfortunately, we are not able to match the working voltage 
    ESDCAN02-2BWY

    ESD2CANFD24DBZRQ1,

    ESD2CANXL24DBZRQ1

    CAN FD <= 5 Mbps

    CAN XL <= 20 Mbps

    Please let me know if you have any additional questions. 

    Best Regards, 

    McKenzie Eaker

  • 0 in reply to McKenzie Eaker
    TI__Expert 4505 points

    Hi Eaker,

    Thank you this is clear, but I have a few questions:

    • ESDCANxx alrernatives: to me we are p2p when looking at the actual DS: can you confirm?
    • TVS: do we have Q1 parts?

    Thanks again,

    Best regards, Antoine

  • 0 in reply to Antoine Chapuis1
    TI__Expert 4400 points

    Hi Antoine, 

    My apologies for the confusion. Hope this will clear it up. 

    1. For ESD2CANxx alternatives, both XL and FD only come in one package (SOT-23/DBZ) that is not p2p to the competitor device. ESD2CAN24-Q1 comes in 2 packages: SOT-23/DBZ and SOT-SC70/DCK. The SOT-SC70 package is p2p (ESD2CAN24DCKRQ1). 
    2. We do not have Q1 parts for the TVS family. Do you have any use cases for TVS being Q1? This can be noted for future developments. 

    Please let me know if you have any more questions. 

    Best Regards, 

    McKenzie 

  • 0 in reply to McKenzie Eaker
    TI__Expert 4505 points

    Hi Eaker,

    Thanks, my comments below:

    McKenzie Eaker said:
    For ESD2CANxx alternatives, both XL and FD only come in one package (SOT-23/DBZ) that is not p2p to the competitor device. ESD2CAN24-Q1 comes in 2 packages: SOT-23/DBZ and SOT-SC70/DCK. The SOT-SC70 package is p2p (ESD2CAN24DCKRQ1). 

    Clear: in that case, can I recommend the DCK ESD2CAN24-Q1 as p2p alternative? the line capacitance of both ST parts is 3pF typical, 3.5pf max. Ours is also 3pF typical, but 5pF max.

    McKenzie Eaker said:
    We do not have Q1 parts for the TVS family. Do you have any use cases for TVS being Q1? This can be noted for future developments. 

    I have no specific use cases in mind, but I am seeing ST TVS diodes AEC-Q101 at my customer, so I'm certain there are.

    Best regards, Antoine

  • +1 in reply to Antoine Chapuis1
    TI__Expert 4400 points

    Hi Antoine, 

    Yes, you can recommend the DCK ESD2CAN24-Q1 as a p2p alternative. This is the best recommendation we have for p2p and auto-qualified. 

    Thank you for letting me know about the AEC-Q101 at your customer. We will note this for the future. 

    Please let me know if you have any additional questions. 

    Best Regards, 

    McKenzie

  • 0 in reply to McKenzie Eaker
    TI__Expert 4505 points

    Thank you McKenzie!