Because of the Thanksgiving holiday in the U.S., TI E2E™ design support forum responses may be delayed the week of November 23.

This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

looking to control a BLDC motor for small plane

Other Parts Discussed in Thread: DRV8301, MOTORWARE, DRV11873, DRV10983, TMS320F28027F, DRV8303, TIDA-00143

So, I bought the C2000 28027F launchpad with the DRV8301 booster pack with the goal of controlling a BLDC motor such as this one http://www.e-fliterc.com/Products/Default.aspx?ProdID=EFLM1120, using a PWM input from an RC controller.

I was able to get the first few motorware labs working, but I ran into some problems with getting Lab5 to work with my own calculated Ki and Kp values. Nevertheless, while looking through TI's sites for a solution to this, I came across another IC which seems to align much better with that I'm trying to accomplish:

The DRV10983 and DRV11873 seem to have the dedicated PWM input pin to use as the input from the RC remote controller. However, I saw that they are mostly used for fan applications, not really small plane motors.

However, if I found a way to amplify the current from them, would it be possible to use them as a speed controller to the motor above?

I am mostly looking at them for a simplification to the TMS320F28027F and DRV8301 launchpad and booster pack solution, as I am unsure how to accomplish this functionality using the instaspin code provided via Motorware.

  • I don't think the DRV10x or 11x can handle the current required, but I sent this to the DRV team to get their feedback.

    I agree that the simplicity of these DRV1x solutions is quite attractive.

  • Well, the idea was to attach my own external FETs, like the ones from the 8301 booster pack.

    This motor is quite small, and I think it can still work adequately without the sophisticated control features like the booster pack offers.

  • if you don't want to engineer the controls why not just buy a standard Hobby ESC?  In the low power levels you can find them for like $6. That's cheaper than you can build one yourself I bet!

  • Yes it would be, but the problem is with this plane, we need everything to be on a small and lightweight PCB. The ESC adds additional weight that we would prefer to avoid.


    Our other IC's (GPS, IMU, Xbee, Pressure,Humidity) are on this PCB as well.

  • But we are looking to mimic the functionality of an ESC which takes a PWM input from a RC controller.

  • Hi Aleksandar,

    Most of the DRV10/11 devices are intended for lower current, PC and server fan applications.

    The best fit would possibly be the DRV10983 but it only goes down to 8V.

    How much current are you looking to drive to the motor (continuous/peak)? I see your motor supports up to 3.2A burst.

  • One of the most difficult challenges in ESC design is increasing power without significantly increasing weight.

  • The DRV10983 cannot be used a "current amplifier" since the MOSFETs are internal. This would not help you anyways since you would need to provide external MOSFETs. At that point you are back to the DRV8301/DRV8303 with an external MCU.

  • I see, but couldn't there be another way to amplify the current coming out of the internal FETs, maybe an op-amp or darlington transistor setup?


    But using another set of nFETS like the ones from the DRV8301 booster pack, but connected to the outputs of the DRV10983, wouldn't work?

  • Hi Aleksandar,

    I don't see a way. The DRV10893 determines when to commutate the motor by monitoring the voltages and current through the internal MOSFETs (sensorless motor control). I do not see anyway to feed these signals from the outside.

    It sounds like you want a black box that will do sensorless brushless motor control for you at higher power. I am afraid we do not have a device that fits this need at the moment and they are fairly rare.

    Most ESCs on the markets are some sort of MCU + Gate Driver + Power MOSFETs combined into a "black box". The MCU takes in a PWM and converts it to the appropriate gate drive control signals.

    You may be able to use the DRV10983 on it's own but I am unsure if it will meet the power requirements you need.

  • Well I originally was planning to use a modified schematic from here: http://www.ti.com/tool/tida-00143#tiDevice,

    and was using the C2000 launchpad and DRV8301 Booster pack to test it.

    However, I noticed that the DRV11873 and DRV10893 have a dedicated PWM input which serves as a speed control pin, which is exactly what I was looking to achieve with the DRV8301 and TMS320F28027F. But to do this, would I have to probably designate a GPIO as a PWM capture, and them add some additional processing within the INSTA-SPIN software to achieve this?

    So, although the MOSFETS are internal for the DRV11873/10893, and can only produce the 1.5 A limited current output (as specified as the DRV11873 for example), my thinking was to add the external FETS in addition to those just as the DRV8301 needs, in order to get that higher current output. Then, I was thinking to connect the source from those FETS each phase of the motor.

    Anyway I appreciate all your help in explaining this matter and I apologize for my lack of knowledge in it, as I am quite inexperienced with motor control.

    Thanks,

    Aleksandar Zivkovic

  • I understand. Yes, you would need to modify the firmware for the F28027 to accept the PWM input as a speed command. This should be fairly simple and I am sure the C2000 forum can assist you.

    You will see that the DRV8301 has signals for the GATE (GL and GH) of the MOSFETs. These are what turn the MOSFETs on and off. The DRV10983 just gives you the switching node which wouldn't actually drive a half-bridge. This is the main difference between a Gate Driver and an Integrated Driver. The DRV10983 has the added benefit of building in the controller has well. Some people like this, but many people like the flexibility to modifiy the controller to their own needs.

    We are happy to help! Feel free to post any questions you have.