Other Parts Discussed in Thread: BQ28Z610
Following up this earlier conversation with Jeff:
The workaround we arrived at in that thread works for batteries that are shut down, but does not work if the battery is dead (CUV) and turned off.
In the shut down case, the fuel gauge (BQ28Z610) just needs to briefly see some voltage on the pack terminal to wake up and enable the discharge FET. But if the battery is dead, the fuel gauge will keep the discharge FET off until the battery trickle charges above CUV. The change-to-1S workaround fails in this case because the charger output is a brief spike before VBAT_OVP stops it, so the battery doesn't get any charge and stays off.
In the old thread, Jeff had not received a root cause explanation from design. I'm still interested in the status of that and whether the device will be fixed. And in the meantime, I need to find another workaround to allow charging dead batteries.
Thanks!