This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

LM2594HMV-AD - Different National and TI Data Sheets

Other Parts Discussed in Thread: LM2594

We designed LM2594HVM-ADJ/NOPB on our SS3 MLB. It has been in production in many year. It is used in a negative switcher topology to generate regulated -15V. The input voltage to the switcher can vary from 19V to 33V. 

 

Recently, it had a failure in the field. This was confirmed by our QA lab.

 

In the old National Semi data sheet (Dec 1999) on page 18, it used to say that it's okay to left the ON/OFF pin open (regulator will be in ON condition). This is how we designed it on our board.

 

ON /OFF —Allows the switching regulator circuit to be shut

down using logic level signals thus dropping the total input

supply current to approximately 80 μA. Pulling this pin below

a threshold voltage of approximately 1.3V turns the regulator

on, and pulling this pin above 1.3V (up to a maximum of 25V)

shuts the regulator down. If this shutdown feature is not

needed, the ON /OFF pin can be wired to the ground pin or

it can be left open, in either case the regulator will be in the

ON condition.

 After TI acquired National Semi, they made revision changes to the data sheet of the National Semi switchers (revised April 2013). I noticed similar changes on other switcher devices. The TI data sheet looks difference. I can't find the note about the ON/OFF pin that said it's okay to leave it open.  I wonder if the change is for the data sheet only or there is actual change made to the regulator IC. Is it still okay to leave the ON/OFF pin open for normal operation? Is there any other actual changes made for LM2594HVM-ADJ/NOPB from Dec 1999 till now?

 

I'll email in the National Semi data sheet for your reference to the ACAT team. The TI data sheet is available thru web.

http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/lm2594.pdf

  • -Adding National Datasheet for Dan

    LM2594.pdf
  • I am looking for information in our team. Will get back to you once I find out.

    Yang

  • Dan,

    The same statement quoted in you post can be found in the new TI LM2594 DS:

    page 19, the ON/OFF session:

    ON /OFF—Allows the switching regulator circuit to be shut down using logic level signals thus dropping the total input supply current to approximately 80μA. Pulling this pin below a threshold voltage of approximately 1.3V turns the regulator on, and pulling this pin above 1.3V (up to a maximum of 25V) shuts the regulator down. If this shutdown feature is not needed, the ON /OFF pin can be wired to the ground pin or it can be left open, in either case the regulator will be in the ON condition.

    I don't think anything has been change on the silicon since TI aquired National.

    regards,

    Yang

  • Thanks for the note back.  I have a follow upquestion: 

    For a negative regulator (-15V), should we connect pin 5 to pin 6 of the regulator (connect ON/OFF pin to -15V)?

    Thanks,

    Dan

  • Dan,

    You are correct. ON/OFF pin should be connected to pin 6, the lowest potential of the IC to keep the IC on all the time.

    Regards,

    Yang

  • Yang,

    My customer still has questions:

    Even though the data sheet said it's okay to leave the ON/OFF pin open, is it better to connect it to the ground pin instead?

    Would it be less sensitive to noise to have the ON/OFF pin connected to the ground pin?

    Would this arrangement be any different for a negative switching regulator?

    Since we have a failure of this regulator in the field, we would like to understand if this is a random failure by chance? A weak component? Should we improve the design to make it less likely to fail?

  • Dan,

    I received information back from our sustaining product engineer regarding your questions. Quote "There is neither change to datasheet nor IC. There is however process change from 6” to 8” wafer size about couple years ago. No fab change." This should not be a reason for increased failure after years of use.

    I am not sure whether connecting the ON/OFF pin to ground is better than leave it float. It shouldn't hurt to connect to GND. When applied to negtive configuration, ON/OFF pin should also connect to the GND pin of the IC, which is the negtive Vout of the converter and the lowest potential of the IC.

    Hope this helps.

    Yang