This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

Need recommendation for protection IC, single-cell applicaion

Other Parts Discussed in Thread: BQ24092, BQ27545-G1, BQ2970, BQ27742-G1

I am designing a circuit for a single-cell Li Polymer battery system.  The battery is a 1000 mAh unit and has internal protection.  The characteristics of the internal sell protection are:

  • over-voltage (over-charge) cutoff point is as low as4.250 V (4.250 to 4.300)
  • under-voltage (over-discharge) cutoff point about 2.5 V

I am considering use of the BQ24092 charger:

  • voltage-regulation at as high as 4.230 V (4.160 to 4.230 V).

I need a protection IC (like the BQ29797 or the MM3511) but both present problems in our application.

The BQ29797 has over-voltage detection at as low as 4.260 V (4.260 to 4.300) which is 30 mV above the charger's maximum regulation voltage -- so far so good.

But the BQ29797 has under-voltage detection at 2.8 V which, because we want long battery life, is lower than we desire.

The MM3511AB6Y has an under-voltage detection point of 3.0 V which is acceptable.

But the MM3511AB6Y has over-voltage detection at as low as 4.200 V (4.200 to 4.250).  The problem here is that the MM3511 could trip on over-voltage before the charger even reached the voltage regulated phase of charging.

Does anyone have a suggestion?  I'd like (ideally) a protection IC that has an over-voltage point of 4.260 to 4.300 V and an under-voltage cutoff at 3.0 or even better 3.1 V.

One final note -- not related to the above.  We are planning to use the BQ27545-G1 fuel gauge.