I have since prototyped the evaluation board based on the BQ24450, found here http://focus.ti.com/lit/ug/sluu464/sluu464.pdf
It appears to test well for our application - the only difference between the default schematic is that we are using a P type FET with a 10K pull up. There is only one remaining outstanding issue.
If the current supplied is more than the current limit, the circuit uses the predicted < 2mA + the current drawn by R5 (we are using a 10K pull up). If however we limit the supply current to less than what the circuit current limit is, the power consumption increases to 6mA + the current drawn by R5.
Can somebody speculate as to what is causing this?
Thanks
Oliver
(I have submitted this as a ticket and to asktexas over a week ago, with still no reply or help)