This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

LMP91000: Component Recommendations for High-Speed, Low-Power, Miniaturized Potentiostat

Part Number: LMP91000
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: LMP91002, OPA3S328,

Tool/software:

Hello TI Support Team,

We are designing a custom, battery-powered potentiostat for a high-speed electrochemical sensing application and would appreciate your component recommendations.

Our primary challenge is balancing speed, resolution, power, and size. The goal is to produce filtered sensor current data at a rate of at least 50 kSPS (a 20 µs interval), with a resolution of 10 nA.

1. Integrated Solutions: Our research has led us to integrated potentiostat AFEs like the LMP91000 or AD5940. However, to achieve high fidelity, low noise data every 20us, after ADC oversampling and decimation filters is not fast enough in most integrated solutions. 

  • Are there any TI integrated potentiostat AFEs that can meet our speed and resolution requirements?
  • Alternatively, could an integrated SOC (with integrated low power ADC, DAC, BLE) work with OTS (LMP91000 etc) or even custom discrete AFE to meet our our performance targets?

2. Discrete Component Requirements: If a fully integrated solution isn't feasible, we are considering a discrete solution. We would appreciate your recommendations for a suitable op-amp (for the TIA), for control amplifier (high current driving capability and slew rate), unity gain buffer and an ADC. Our key requirements are summarized below.

  • Overall Performance
    • Measurement Goal: Capture input current transients up to a maximum of 20 µA.
      1. Resolution: At least 10 nA.
      2. Data Rate: Provide a final, oversampled and filtered data point every 20 µs or faster (≥ 50 kSPS - not raw unfiltered sampling).
  • Component Specifications
    1. Transimpedance Amplifier (TIA):
      1. Must be fast enough to accurately capture the current transient within the 20 µs window.
      2. Needs ultra-low noise, low input bias current, and low offset/drift to resolve 10 nA. A FET-input is highly preferred.
    2. Control Amplifier
      1. Must have high current driving capability and sufficient slew rate to drive electrochemical cell from DAC output.
    3. Unity Gain Buffer
      1. Needs ultra-low noise, low input bias current, and low offset/drift to resolve 10 nA. A FET-input is highly preferred.
    4. Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC):
      1. Resolution: 16-24 bits (to minimize quantization noise).
      2. Sampling Rate: Must be high enough to allow for oversampling and digital filtering to achieve the final ≥ 50 kSPS data rate (1 MSPS+).
  • System Constraints
    1. A single positive supply is strongly preferred to reduce solution size.
    2. The device is battery-powered, so low quiescent current (Iq) is critical for all component selections. We would be open to using SW controlled FETs to turn off AFE for power savings in case low power parts don't meet performance or size specs. 
    3.  A compact footprint is a key design driver.
  • Development Support
    1. Finally, development support is a critical factor in our component selection.
    2. Parts with available evaluation kits, reference designs, or firmware examples would be highly preferred to help accelerate our design cycle.

Thank you for your time and assistance.

  • Raza,

    Thanks for reaching out. The LMP91000 has most of what you are looking for integrated into a single chip, just not the ADC. The LMP91000 should also be able to handle your design goals. If you want to not use the LMP91000 and set up your own potentiostat circuit, I recommend reading this app note from Alphasense that describes how to do so:

    https://www.alphasense.com/-/media/project/oneweb/oneweb/alphasense/products/application-notes/aan_105-03_app-note_v0.pdf?revision=2de3db93-89a0-4db9-bfdb-6b2767f15d44

    There is also an EVM for the LMP91000 that you can use as a starting point for your design, and basic experimentation with a chemical cell:

    https://www.ti.com/tool/LMP91000EVM

    Regards

    -Alex Thompson

  • Thanks for your response.

    1. My concern is whether LMP91000 is fast enough for our application. I am unable to find information regarding bandwidth specs of its internal TIA. Could you share more details about LMP91000 speed and noise performance for our application. 

    2. Can LMP91000's Vout drive an ADC input directly, or we need intermediary ADC driver? Also, which 16bit+ 1Msps+ SAR ADC (with SPI interface) from TI do you think would work best with LMP91000 to capture data at very high speeds such that after oversampling and decimation filters, we still retain atleast 50ksps-100ksps?

    3. Is there any other advantage of using LMP91000 compared to AD5940? One could be flexibility of using a 20bit+ 1Msps+ ADC instead of being restricted by internal ADC of AD5940. How does LMP91000 compare against LMP91002?

    4. In case we want to design our own AFE that is faster, how would OPA3S328 function, with high bandwidth, we could increase our gain and our current resolution? Are there any other parts you would recommend for us to consider looking at. 

    Thanks!

  • Raza,

    I don't have the additional information on the TIA bandwidth that you are looking for unfortunately. So I cant say whether or not the LMP91000 will be fast enough for your application. 

    The LMP91000 can drive an ADC input directly. On the LMP91000EVM, the LMP91000 is directly connected to a ADS161S626 ADC. Now this ADC does not match your desired sampling rate, but I would use the EVM to try some different ADCs. You can disconnect the ADS161S626 on the EVM by changing jumpers on VOUT, so that you can connect your own ADC to the VOUT. I recommend you try that to see if the LMP91000 is really going to work for your application. 

    The advantage that I see of the LMP91000 over the AD5940 is reduced complexity and lack of an integrated ADC. Because the ADC is not integrated, you can add your own with that ever resolution and speed you desire.

    The LMP91002 is a spin of the LMP91000, where the bias voltage functionality is removed. This makes it compatible with chemical cells that require zero bias.

    If you want to design an AFE with your own TIA, you will need to make a post about that amplifier in a separate thread. I cannot answer those questions for you.

    Regards

    -Alex Thompson