CC2531: Z-Stack sampleswitch example dont work as expected.

I suspect you don’t do binding successfully. Please attach your sniffer log.

Hi

Thanks for your reply.

Here you can find the Log:

https://pastebin.com/DUavkRvs

Here you can find the full pcapng file

http://bit.do/SniffDetails

00:12:4b:00:0f:ea:70:d6

is the device which does not send any switch commands

Thank you for your support

Hi Claudio,

I agree with YK that binding is the most probable cause.  Is the ZC running a SampleLight application?  Is ZCL_EZMODE defined in your project?  Have you successfully operated these examples in the past?  Also, why not evaluate Z-Stack 3.0.2 with BDB commissioning?  Please note that my firewall prevents access to your sniffer logs, please upload them directly to the E2E thread if possible.

Regards,
Ryan

Thanks for your answer.

I have made it available through a url-shortener to keep crawlers away from the URL behind.

Actual settings are:

HOLD_AUTO_START - Disabled (xHOLD_AUTO_START)
ZTOOL_P1 - Disabled (xZTOOL_P1)
LCD_SUPPORTED=DEBUG - Disabled (xLCD_SUPPORTED=DEBUG)
ZCL_EZMODE - Disabled (xZCL_EZMODE)

Other settings are as in the original

I have disabled EZMODE since i am using a coordinator and dont want that devices connect to each other without a coordinator.

Whenever i try to upload the file to the forum it shows me the file as a big image and when i click "reply" it says that an error has occured.

SniffDetails.zip

Your explanation for disabling EZMODE does not make since, but as you have disabled it then you will have to share your manual bind process.  A bind is required to send the message formed by zclGeneral_SendOnOff_CmdToggle.

Regards,
Ryan

Hi Ryan

Thanks for your answer.

Ok, then perhaps i misunderstood the meaning of the EZMODE.
Should i activate it again? I thought the EZMODE allows connections between two devices without coordinator.

(i have just tried to enable EZMODE and pressed the button... Still no avtivity on wireshark)

Also, why not evaluate Z-Stack 3.0.2 with BDB commissioning?

Because my concentrator is based on 1.2.2. Therefore i thought to avoid some, for me actually unknown, potential problems, i better use 1.2.2
If i understood the theory of operation, i will try to use 3.0.2.

Have you successfully operated these examples in the past?

No.. This is the first time.

Is the ZC running a SampleLight application?

The ZC is a Zigbee2MQTT Concentrator. which is based on the ZNP Project.

but as you have disabled it then you will have to share your manual bind process.  A bind is required to send the message formed by zclGeneral_SendOnOff_CmdToggle.

I would be happy to share the process with you. Do you mean the messages from wireshark?
Cause there is not activity at all during my button press.

Thanks

## EDIT

I have changed

NLME_SetPollRate( ZDApp_SavedPollRate );

in ZDApp.c

to

NLME_SetPollRate( 0);

Otherwise there is every 2 seconds a Data Request and a ACK on Wireshark.
What is this polling good for?

Thanks

Thank you for your quick answer.

Ok isee, i mixed up some very different things.

One last question to you.

Ive found this project:

https://github.com/dzungpv/dnckatsw00x

Is the ZCL_ReportCommand the code you mentioned?

//report state for button 1
  zclSampleLightSeqNumState++;
  zclReportCmd_t rptcmd;
  rptcmd.numAttr = 1;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrID = ATTRID_ON_OFF;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].dataType = ZCL_DATATYPE_BOOLEAN;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrData = (void *)(&zclSampleLight_OnOff);

  // Set destination address to indirect
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addrMode = (afAddrMode_t)Addr16Bit;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addr.shortAddr = 0;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.endPoint=1;
  zcl_SendReportCmd(SAMPLELIGHT_ENDPOINT,&zclSampleLight_DstAddr, ZCL_CLUSTER_ID_GEN_ON_OFF, &rptcmd, ZCL_FRAME_SERVER_CLIENT_DIR, true, zclSampleLightSeqNumState );
  //report state for button 2
  zclSampleLightSeqNumState++;
  zclReportCmd_t rptcmd;
  rptcmd.numAttr = 1;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrID = ATTRID_ON_OFF;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].dataType = ZCL_DATATYPE_BOOLEAN;
  rptcmd.attrList[0].attrData = (void *)(&zclSampleLight_OnOff1);

  // Set destination address to indirect
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addrMode = (afAddrMode_t)Addr16Bit;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.addr.shortAddr = 0;
  zclSampleLight_DstAddr.endPoint=1;
  zcl_SendReportCmd(SAMPLELIGHT_ENDPOINT+1,&zclSampleLight_DstAddr, ZCL_CLUSTER_ID_GEN_ON_OFF, &rptcmd, ZCL_FRAME_SERVER_CLIENT_DIR, true, zclSampleLightSeqNumState );

Or in other words. Am i on the right way when i use his project as a base?

Thanks

Yes, zcl_SendReportCmd is the API to send zcl report.

zcl_SendReportCmd is not the same as AF_DataRequest (it resides a layer upstream before eventually calling it) but the important part is that, contrary to the comments in the code excerpt, indirect addressing (afAddrMode_t)AddrNotPresent; is not used since a bind has not been created.  The code excerpt implies a report command sent directly to short address 0x0000, also known as the Zigbee coordinator, intended for endpoint 0x01.

Regards,
Ryan