• State Resolved
  • Locked Locked
  • Replies 12 replies
  • Answers 2 answers
  • Subscribers 78 subscribers
  • Views 1883 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Support feedback
Options
Options
Similar topics

This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

Original question:

MSP432E401Y: MSP432E401 TCP send

MSP432E401Y: ICMP (ping) checksum is set to 0

Horst Eyermann89
Prodigy 150 points
Part Number: MSP432E401Y

we are using the MSP401E401Y Launchpad to test lwIP.

When using the lwip Ethernet example the ICMP (ping) Response has the ICMP checksum set to 0 (the IP checksum is correct)

* on Linux I see the ping Response, but Wireshark Shows that the ICMP checksum is set to 0

* Windows does not Display a response

On both Systems I can open the Webpage from the demo with no issues (under the same IP address) .

How to get the ping Response to work?

  • 0
    TI__Mastermind 22580 points
    Hello Horst,

    Which example are you using? Can you point to the location of the example and the version of the SDK?

    Thanks,
    Sai
  • 0 in reply to Sai Reddy
    Prodigy 150 points

    Hello Sai,

    I am using the Ethernet_with_lwip - NoRtos - CCS Compiler example. See Resource Explorer screenshot below for Details

  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    Prodigy 150 points

    Hello Sai,

    was the Information sufficient, do you Need more Details?

    Could you reproduce the behaviour? 

    Thanks,

    Horst

  • 0 in reply to Sai Reddy
    Prodigy 150 points
    Hello Sai,

    I have not seen a Response to the Question with the ping (ICMP) issue.

    Can you please give me a Status update.
    What Action can i take?

    Thanks,
    Horst
  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    TI__Mastermind 22580 points
    Hello Horst,

    Apologize for the delay in response!

    Did you already try to enable the ICMP by uncommenting the following line in the file lwipopts.h of the example?
    //#define LWIP_ICMP 1

    Let me know if uncommenting the above line works! If it does not work I will work on reproducing the issue.

    Thanks,
    Sai
  • 0 in reply to Sai Reddy
    Prodigy 150 points

    Hello Sai,

    thank you for your response. As per request, I did enable ICMP. However, as expeceted, the result was the same as before.

    I do get a ping reply, but the ICMP checksum is set to 0x0000 (incorrect).

    The response caputured with Wireshark:

    It would be good, if you could look into it. Please let me know, if I can provide you with more Information.

    Best regards,

    Horst

  • 0 in reply to Sai Reddy
    Prodigy 150 points

    Hello Sai,

    as I have mentioned before, uncommenting the line you mentioned did not resolve the problem.

    did you get a chance to setup a system and reproduce the behaviour? - Is there another way for me to get support from TI?

    Thank you,

    Horst

  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    Prodigy 150 points

    Hello Sai,

    did you manage to test the ping response?

    Thanks,

    Horst

  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    TI__Mastermind 22580 points

    Hello Horst,

    Apologize for not getting back earlier!

    I think the issue is that lwIP is not generating checksum. In SimpleLink MSP432E4 SDK, the default lwIP configuration is used, which is for software to generate checksum for outgoing lwIP ICMP packets. For some reason this is not happening (I still have to figure out why).

    Since MSP432E4 can generate this checksum in hardware, if we enabl this feature then checksum is generated for outgoing ICMP packets and ping is working (I tested in Windows).

    To enable hardware to generate checksum for outgoing ICMP packets, use the following line of code in lwipopts.h.

    //*****************************************************************************
//
// ---------- checksum options ----------
//
//*****************************************************************************
//#define CHECKSUM_GEN_IP                 1
#define CHECKSUM_GEN_ICMP               0
//#define CHECKSUM_GEN_UDP                1
//#define CHECKSUM_GEN_TCP                1
//#define CHECKSUM_CHECK_IP               1
//#define CHECKSUM_CHECK_UDP              1
//#define CHECKSUM_CHECK_TCP              1

    I made this change and windows accepts all the ICMP packets from MSP432E4. See screenshot below.

    Hope this works for you!

    Thanks,

    Sai

  • 0 in reply to Sai Reddy
    Prodigy 150 points

    indeed this works for me.

    When disabling the ICMP checksum, the correct checksum is transmitted.

    Note: actually Looking in the data in function msp432e4if_transmit (in msp432e4if.c) Shows that lwIP did generate the checksum, but somehow MSP432E4 did overwrite the checksum with  0x0000 when sending out the packet.

    Thanks,

    Horst 

  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    Prodigy 150 points
    Actually, doing more testing, it seems that in lwIP (lwipopts.h) we can also Change:


    #define CHECKSUM_GEN_IP 0
    #define CHECKSUM_GEN_ICMP 0
    #define CHECKSUM_GEN_UDP 0
    #define CHECKSUM_GEN_TCP 0


    ==> MSP432E4 can calculate These checksums in HW


    what do you think?
  • 0 in reply to Horst Eyermann89
    TI__Mastermind 22580 points

    Hello Horst,

    Yes you can! That would move the checksum generation for all those protocols to the Hardware.

    I believe if you make the following changes, the hardware will manage verifying the checksum. I will have to confirm this though!
    #define CHECKSUM_CHECK_IP 0
    #define CHECKSUM_CHECK_UDP 0
    #define CHECKSUM_CHECK_TCP 0

    I will file a enhancement request to validate and make these changes part of the example generation process.

    Thanks for looking into this and being patient with us!

    Regards,
    Sai

**Attention** This is a public forum