LM193: Overfrequency usage

Part Number: LM193
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: LM139,

Dear Experts,

We are evaluating LM139, and some of the input frequencies may be at 5MHz or 10MHz. We would like to know what state this input frequency will cause the output to become and what impact it will have on the output. Thank you

  • 5MHz and 10MHz is way too fast.

    Max toggle rate is ftoggle = 1/( TPHL + TPLH +tr + tf)

    For the LM193 family, conservatively:

    Ftoggle = 1 / (1.3u + 1.3u + 100n + 100n) = 357kHz. 

    The output would either not even respond, or it may "stick" high. No way to predict.

    For 10MHz, 1/10MHz = 100ns period. There are two transitions in a period, so the comparator needs to be twice as fast.

    A comparator would have to have *minimum* of 50ns prop delay. And that is not assuming a "nice" output (ignoring rise/fall times).

    If you want a clean, symmetrical output, you should add at least a 20-30% margin. I would stay below 30ns.

    Do you need the low temperature (-55) or high voltage? (30V)

    Most of the "fast" comparators (sub 50ns) will be 5V max supply.