This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

Recommended differential amplifier

Expert 1800 points
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: TLC2274, OPA320, OPA350, OPA365

Hi,

 

I have 0.005 Ohm current sense resistor for a motor control application (PMSM).  What's the best differential amplifier to measure the current (max 10 A) using kelvin connection. 

i.e., V=IR

Drop across current resistor = 0.005*1 (@ 1 Amp) = 0.005 V.  This is very low voltage drop.

Any referense schematics would be of great help.

thanks and regards

 

  • Hello,

    It is difficult to provide a recommendation without more information.  Could you provide a little more information about the application?

    What are the supply voltage requirements for the op-amp?

    Is it a high-side or low-side current measurement?

    If it is a high-side measurement, what is the supply rail of the motor application that the signal will be biased at?  (What is the common-mode voltage input?)

    Finally what is the switching frequency of the motor-drive circuitry?

    We look forward to working with you.

    Best Regards,
    Collin Wells
    Linear Applications

  • Hi Collin,

    Thanks for the response.  Pl find below the info requested.

    1)  What are the supply voltage requirements for the op-amp?

    The bus voltage is 48V while the Op-amp would be supplied 3.3V.

    2) Is it a high-side or low-side current measurement?

    Its the low side current measurement.

    3) If it is a high-side measurement, what is the supply rail of the motor application that the signal will be biased at?  (What is the common-mode voltage input?)

    Answered as above.

    4) Finally what is the switching frequency of the motor-drive circuitry?

    The switching frequency is 15KHz  (25KHz max.)

    The schematics is similar to DMC550 and DMC1500 power board from spectrum digital.  Currently they have implemented TLC2274 op amp for current sensing while I would wish to implement kelvin connection in its place for better response.  The max current is extimated approx. 30A.

    Pl review and let me know if you need any more information.

    thx & rgds

  • Hello,

    Thank you for the information.  For a low-side current measurement we would suggest the OPA320.  It has a common-mode input range that extends 100mV lower than the negative supply rail (V-  - 100mV), high CMRR, and a max input offset voltage of 150uV. 

    For higher output drive or bandwidth, look at the OPA350, or OPA365, they both have a common-mode input range that goes below the V- supply like the OPA320. 

    The TLC2274 would work as well, but the common-mode input range is limited to the negative supply (V-), and the max input offset voltage is higher at over 2mV.

    Thanks and Best Regards,
    Collin Wells
    Precision Analog
    Linear Applications

  • Thanks for the info.  Could you please let me know how to give kelvin connection with the suggested op amps so that I get accurate measurements considering the effect of resistances at the soldered joints.  Any reference schematics would be of great help.

    thx & rgds

  • Hello,

    Please find a schematic attached for a low-side current sense application using the OPA320.  I modified the schematic you submitted to the "SPICE" forum using the TLC2274.  I maintained most of your component values and have included the math I used to calculate the component values that were changed.

    To minimize errors when performing current shunt measurements during PCB layout, be sure to take connect the inputs to the amplifier directly at the shunt resistor terminals.  Connecting the inputs close by on a plane or through a wire will induce errors due to the PCB resistances.  

    In the case of the schematic below, be sure to connect R83 and R4 directly at the R2 shunt resistor terminals on the PCB. Connect the GND connection of R4 directly at the GND of the sense resistor to minimize any errors due to GND plane resistances (small as they may be). 

    The circuit provides a linear output from roughly 0V to 3V with a 0 - 10A input current through a 5mOhm sense resistor.

    The negative output stage saturates at around 10mV and measurements below 50mA are not possible with this design.

    Please let me know if you have any further questions.

    Regards,
    Collin Wells
    Linear Applications 

     

    Low-Side Current Sense.TSC
  • Thanks for the info and the schematics.  Really nice of you sending them.

    I have a query. 

    1)  Could I use OPA320 amplifier if the motor works as a generator i.e., the direction of current would be reverse.  Probably if you look at the TLC2274 schematics it has a mid point setting to take care of this requirement.

    Please suggest.

    2)  Could you suggest how to implement a kelvin connection for motor controller.


    The 4-Wire 'Kelvin' method (circuit 4) is used in difficult cases when lead resistances vary, RX is very small, or when very high accuracy is required. The method is immune to the influence of lead resistance and is limited by the quality of the constant current source and voltage measurement. Thermo-electric voltages can be eliminated by averaging two measurements with the polarity of the excitation current reversed.

    http://www.arab-training.com/vb/t13647.html

    please suggest

    thx

  • Hello,

    1.)  The circuit I previously provided would not work if the current source went negative.  Below please find a schematic showing a modified version of the midpoint circuit that was in your original design.  I've included the math required to get the circuit to operate.  I chose to center the output voltage at 1.65V and designed for a span of 3V for the 20A current range.  This prevents the both the positive and negative output stages from saturating during operation by limiting the output swing from 0.15V to 3.15V off a +3.3V supply.

     

    2.)  I may be misinterpreting what you're asking here, so please correct me if needed.  The "Kelvin" or 4-wire measurement technique is typically referred to when measuring small resistances by forcing a current through the resistor and then measuring the voltage drop across it.  Because the lead resistances of the probes have voltage drops of their own when current passes through them, the measurement accuracy is affected.  4-wire measurements solve this issue by using separate force and sense probes.  The sense probes are very high-impedance so the measurement is not affected by them. 

    In this case you are not trying to measure resistance, you're trying to measure the current with a known resistance.  The force and sense lines are already separate because the forced current is from the motor load and the sense lines are the high-impedance inputs of the OPA320.  Please follow the layout advice in the previous post to minimize any PCB resistance errors.
    2046.Low-Side Current Sense - BiDirectional.TSC

    Best regards,
    Collin Wells
    Precision Analog
    Linear Applications

     

  • Dear Mr.Colin,

    Thanks for the clarification and I appreciate your efforts.   The answer 1 is pretty clear.  Would you suggest to incorporate a differential amplifier such as OP 07 for measurement at the shunts as I believe there would be lot of noise from ground. Please suggest.

    Your understanding of kelvin connection is excellent and based on the explanation provided using OPA320 would serve the purpose (by taking care of PCB resistance errors).  Could you confirm my understanding.  I would like to know the sensitivity of the op amp OPA 320 i.e., does it function or sense even at very low current values such as 0.1 amp or less than this.

    regards

     

  • Collin,

     

    I have 0.005 Ohm current sense resistor.  What's the best differential amplifier to measure the current (max 500mA). 

    Specifications

    1) High side current measurement

    2) The bus voltage is 125V while the Op-amp would be supplied 5V.

    3) need to measurement the current in both the directions

    OPA350 is suitable for this application?

    V=IR Drop across current resistor = 0.005*5m = 25uV, this is very small voltage

    Any referense schematics would be of great help.

    thanks and regards

    Ramakrishna