This thread has been locked.
If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.
Tool/software: WEBENCH® Design Tools
I have used the work bench to create work bench with inuts of
Vin min : 24V
Vin max : 30V
Vout ; 24V
Iout: 16A
I see two mosfets in parallel on the top part of the H bridge, why is there unequal distribution and can it be replaced by one big mosfet.
Hi Nidhi,
Normally we can observe the parallel fets for high current input cases. This is might be due to the single fet solution for that particular fet is not feasible as it might be hitting maximum junction temperature.
We can always select another fet solution through select alternate option. Please look for fet (M1,M2) quantity equal to 1 and select that solution. I went ahead and created one example work bench for your input case( below link). Hope this helps.
Work bench: https://webench.ti.com/appinfo/webench/scripts/SDP.cgi?ID=FC38F41C0871F167
How to choose alternate Fets:
Best Regards,
Bhushan
I changed the mosfets but unable to redue that M1 pair as the junction temperature is being exceeded. I don't understand the voltage being dropped to 21.8V. As I have one of the components which will not be functional below 21.6V. How can I prevent this? Why is the dip seen?
Hi Nidhi,
Could you please try out the workbench which I have shared below ? It has both pairs with quantity 1 mosfets.
Work bench with both pairs of single mosfet: https://webench.ti.com/appinfo/webench/scripts/SDP.cgi?ID=622BD3CBD349A766
As per my understanding you are referring to load transient simulations. This gives information on overshoot/undershoot if Iout is suddenly drops/ups between 16A and 1.6 A (for your input case).
Overshoot/ undershoot at Vout are mostly depend on
1. How much big the change in Iout we are expecting in our application ( for example design above Iout change is from 16A to 1.6A)
2. How big is our output capacitor ( the bigger cap --> lower the shoot)
3. How sudden is the change in load. (lesser the time more the shoot)
All the above points can be udpated in the Webench to meet transient requirements. If we are not expecting this much transient, please modify the above work bench as per your requirements. I would suggest you to check out steady state waveform as well.
Best Regards,
Bhushan
Actually there's one spike for the variation and there is another spoke post that which I don't understand. The link which you sent was for 30 deg ambient. My max ambient temperature is 60 deg C
Hi Nidhi,
Thanks for your patience here and sorry for delayed reply. This seems to be Pspice model issue with mode transition between pure buck to pure buck-boost mode of operation. This should not reflect in actual IC.
Best Regards,
Bhushan
Hello Bhushan,
Is there any particular reason that M1 & M2 cannot be changed individually?
Hi Nidhi,
Currently the fet selection happens as a pair (for synchronous converter) and not as a single fet. The algorithm will check if mosfets as a pair works for the particular input case or not. For your case (LM5175), we will not be able select the fets separately.
But we can always look for alternate solutions as well. Please follow below steps. Hope this helps.
1. Click on below link.
https://webench.ti.com/power-designer/switching-regulator?powerSupply=
2. Add your inputs (Vin, Vout, Iout) and click on view designs. Webench should give you possible list of solutions
Best Regards,
Bhushan
I have attached my design I just wanted to go about the simulation and I cannot seem to get these specs matched again. Why i that? was this design created as a glitch?WBDesign11_Input Transient-2.pdf
Hi Nidhi,
Could you please help us understand the query here? Are we having different BOM for same input condition compared to earlier design ?
Best Regards,
Bhushan
So I am not able to select the same mosfets I just wanted to do some changes and then some simulations and I see i cannot choose the same configuration as specified in the attachment. Are you able to do it?
Hi Nidhi,
As we are following up on same query on below post. I will be closing this thread. Hope this is fine.
https://e2e.ti.com/support/tools/sim-hw-system-design/f/234/t/907313
Best Regards,
Bhushan