This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

TLV62569: Question about input voltage

Part Number: TLV62569
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: TLV62565, TPS62A02

Dear TI experts,

I asked review of schematic 4 months ago ;

https://e2e.ti.com/support/power-management-group/power-management/f/power-management-forum/1183699/tlv62569-thinkware/4473865#4473865

Actually my customer did lots of tests so far. and they have a related question.

they tested with a standard ISO-7637-2. I think that you already know this standard, but I attach a pdf document for you.

ISO-7637-2-2004.pdf

We found that the worst case of input voltage is "Pulse 1" and "Pulse 5b". Please refer the waveform below.

-> Pulse 1

-> Pulse 5b

As You can see, Pulse1 is the waveform that is very close to Vin recommended input range, and Pulse 5b is very close to Vin absolute maximum rating input range. (please see the spike voltage which can found every 20 seconds)

the important thing is that they tested 5,000 times with this input voltage, but the IC is okay and works well.

But my customer worries that this kind of waveform can slightly damage the IC, and finally not working.

so my final question is ; Is it okay with this kinds of input voltage applied to Vin? or is there any possibility to damage the IC with those input voltage?

Please check this issue. Thanks.

Best regards,

Chase

  • Hi Chase,

    The voltage within the recommended operating condition for the device should be okay and should not cause any damage to the IC. However, the second condition "Pulse 5b" exceeds the recommended max condition and is seen every 20 seconds. Frequent application of this pulse might degrade the lifetime of the device and eventually damage it. Although, it would not damage the device immediately, the lifetime of the device could not be guaranteed in such conditions. 

    Do you know why do they observe frequent pulses like shown in pulse 5b?  

    Thanks!

    Best regards

    Sneha 

  • Dear Sneha,

    Thank you for your support.

    As you know, we discussed about this issue for a long time. this problem is still happened now, and their end customer thinks this is critical problem.

    They just assume that the input of TLV62569 is like pulse 5b, so they can expect the possibility of defect.

    So do you think that this kind of pulse could damage the device, and It can be die in a short time?

    Best regards,

    Chase

  • Hi Chase,

    Pulse like 5b exceeds the recommended operating condition for the device. Even though it is for a short duration, but these pulses are repetitve. Thats why I am concerned that it might degrade the lifetime of the device. The graph below shows device behavior within the recommended operating condition and upto Abs max rating. 

    Will the customer be open to look into other alternatives? For ex: TPS62A02, this is the newest addition to our portfolio with more Vin robustness and TLV62565, this is p2p to TLV62569, with higher abs max rating up to 7V.

    Let me know your thoughts.

    Thanks!

    Best regards

    Sneha 

  • Dear Sneha,

    Thank you for your support.

    I saw the datasheet of TPS62A02, ABS maximum rating is 6V, same as TPS62569.

     Of course it would be very helpful if you recommend other IC to solve this problem.

    Please confirm it. Thanks.

    Best regards,

    Chase

  • Hi Chase, 

    TLV62565 has an ABS max rating of 7V. Would that be of interest to the customer?

    https://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/tlv62565.pdf?ts=1685019788469&ref_url=https%253A%252F%252Fwww.google.com%252F

    Let me know. Thanks!

    Best regards

    Sneha 

  • Hi Chase,

    Do you have further update here? 

    Thanks!

    Best regards

    Sneha 

  • Dear Sneha,

    Thank you for your support. I am still discuss this issue with my customer.

    I will check the status for further questions.

    Best regards,

    Chase

  • Hi Chase, 

    Okay. Keep me posted once you get an update from them.

    Thanks! 

    Best regards

    Sneha 

  • Dear Sneha,

    Thank you for your support.

    I got an email from my customer.

    They suggested about changing TLV62569 to TLV62565, as you recommended.

    and their end customer requested about more information about absolute maximum input voltage of TLV62565.

    1. Do you have any data of TLV62565 like below diagram? (below image is about TLV62569, as you pasted before.)

    Because the end customer wants to compare the graph between TLV62569 and TLV62565.

    2. Do you have more specific data about the diagram above, about TLV62569 and TLV62565?

    The end customer want to know the approximate figure of Y axis in that graph.

    Please check this issue. Thanks.

    Best regards,

    Chase

  • Hi Chase,

    The basic representation for the graph would not change for TLV62565. Only the values would differ as below:

    The typical input voltage = 5V, the recommended max input voltage is 5.5V and the ABS max rating is 7V. So the margin is of 2V between ABS max and typical condition. However, we still recommend to have the input voltage upto 5.5V only.

    Regarding the diagram, it is a graphical representation to show the reliability. The green area represents the most reliable operating condition. However, within the restricted application, we do not guarantee the behavior and it could start degrading the lifetime of the device, even if it is not immediately damaged. Above Abs max rating, it could damage the device and we cannot guarantee the operation.

    Thanks!

    Best regards

    Sneha