This thread has been locked.

If you have a related question, please click the "Ask a related question" button in the top right corner. The newly created question will be automatically linked to this question.

LM5176: Constant Current Loop ans SS pin for input/output Power Limiting

Part Number: LM5176
Other Parts Discussed in Thread: LMV431A, LM5175, INA213, INA214, LMV431, TLV431

Dear Garrett,

i'm sorry for my delay, i tried to analyze the circuit you provided in https://e2e.ti.com/support/power-management/f/196/t/889467

So i set the input power limit to 24W and the input voltage goes from 9V to 27V, so i calculated the current limits that we have to program

Pin [W] 24 24 24 24 24
Vin[V] 27 24 18 12 9
Iin [A] 0.888889 1 1.333333 2 2.666667

After that i set the Rsense to 15mOhm and the gain of opmap to 100V/V and calculated the Vout of OPAMP

Rsens[Ohm] 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015
Vsense [V] 0.013333 0.015 0.02 0.03 0.04
Gain [V/V] 100 100 100 100 100
Vout [V] 1.333333 1.5 2 3 4

According to http://www.ti.com/lit/an/slva861/slva861.pdf?ts=1588679107379 i set the RFBT= 10KOhm , RFBB= 10KOhm and Rdac to 4.99kOhm

so i get for different Vdac always 1.24V on REF pin of LMV431A for current limit. 

Vref [V] 1.24 1.24 1.24 1.24 1.24
Vdac [V] 1.812187 1.72902 1.47952 0.98052 0.48152

now if the current input limit is exceeded The REF pin will go above 1.24V.

Now this REF pin is compared to internal 1.24V ref of the LMV431A

1) if the voltage on REF pin is greater than internal 1.24V ref  what will then happen ?

in one of you videos (3:15)

(https://www.ti.com/power-management/voltage-reference/shunt-voltage-reference/overview.html -> Learn more about shunt voltage references -> Voltage Reference Use Cases)

it says if the sensed voltage is grater than internal then the shunt regulator pulls to cathode and if it is less than internal then pulls to GND, what does this mean?

You only said in your schematic " Pulls down to create current limit" 

"When the current sens signal voltage is higher than the reference voltage the voltage reference pulls down the ISNS- pin engaging the internsl average loop current loop and limiting the input current."

 

I don't understand this

2) when the current limit is exceeded then the sensed REF pin is greater then internal 1.24V ref and the shunt pulls to cathode.

what is then the voltage across anode and cathode of the LMV431A , what is the current that is going through LMV431A ?

3) You said " The 20kOhm value just ensure that the Voltage reference doesn't exceed the rated voltage."

how is the 20Kohm resistor calculated? Also when it this calculated when REF>1.24 , REF=1.24V or REF<1.24V?

What is the voltage across 20kOmh when  REF>1.24 , REF=1.24V or REF<1.24V?

4)You said "the 100ohm just allows for a small voltage drop across the ISNS= and ISNS- pins"

form the  LM5175 DS we see that when the current sense gm amplifier outputs grater than 50mV then the Css is discharged .

so when i have 100ohm across ISNS pins this means when REF=1.24V then current through 100ohm is 50mV/100Ohm= 0.5mA if the REF>1.24V then this current through 100ohm resistor is greater and Css starts discharging.

How is this resistor calculated?

Because the ISNS+ == Vin and Vin is not always the same

R=(Vin- Visns)/(0.5mA) when REF=1.24V -> does this mean for different VIn the voltage across 20kohm or across LMV431A will not be the same?

5) how is the 10nF cap and 0R selected, simulated or calculated?

Best Regards,

David.

  • Hi d_zero,

    Thank your for posting.  It is a long post.  We are studying this and will get back to you by Thu.

    Thanks,

    Youhao Xi, Applications Engineering

  • Dear Youhao,

    later i made a simplified simulation (please check attached) 

    LMV431A.TSC

    And i think i know how it is working now, please can you confirm

    a) when external REF<1.24V ( internal ref from LMV431A) then the LMV431A is not conducting and has across cathode and anode  the Vin voltage 

    in my case this is up to 27V and in DS of LMV431A cathode voltage is 30V with ABS 35V

    question: in order t use LMV431A our Vin voltage can't exceed 30V?

    b) when external REF=1.24V  ( internal ref from LMV431A) ( current limit tripped) then the LMV431A starts conducting ( and REF voltage goes higher)  and when the current through  LMV431A  and 100Ohm reaches to be 50mV = I_conduct * 100R, then will the internal of LM517X start discharging the Css.

    c) when external REF>1.24V ( internal ref from LMV431A) then the LMV431A conducts and the current is limited with 20kOhm so that it not exceeds the cathode current of LMV431A = 15mA 

    question: with 20kOhm the current is around 1mA , do you see a problem if i change the resistor to 10kOhm then the current is around 2mA?

    d) i also think that 100Ohm is reasonable for this configuration .

    e) the question regarding 10nF and 0R remains: how is the 10nF cap and 0R selected, simulated or calculated?

    f) now i also looked regarding the proposed current sense opamp INA213 ( 50V/V), but i calculated 100V/V gain so INA214 would be the way to go, but i looked at other of your opamps and my opamp Vout is not more than 5V would you recommend INA180A3 ( accepts 5V supply)  over INA214 ( accepts 15V supply)?

    Best Regards.

  • Hi d_zero,

    The reference needs to be configured correctly with the feedback included. Please see the attached filed.

    /cfs-file/__key/communityserver-discussions-components-files/196/3125.LMV431A.TSC

    This should help in understanding the circuit

    -Garrett

  • Hi Garrett,

    thanks for the updated simulation.

    Please if you can answer the other questions?  Regarding feedback calculation, opamp ( INA214 or INA180A3)  that i selected and if ok to change from 20kOhm to 10kOhm for LMV431?

    Best Regards.

  • D_Zero,

    There should be no issue on changing the resistor from 20kOhm to 10kOhm. The voltage reference is rated to sink up to 30mA.

    In this application the TLV431 is being used as an error amplifier. This is very similar to the how an isolated flyback converter implements feedback. 10nF was selected to set the cut off frequency of the average current limit loop lower than the voltage loop cut off frequency. 10nF is good for most current limiting applications. this can be simulated with a simple transient simulation

    Regarding the question about the current sense amplifier, I suggest creating a post about that specific topic. I don't don't want to provide incorrect answers for to you. An engineer of the group will be better suited to help you.

    Thanks,

    Garrett